Imagine the thrill of a second chance in baseball – that's exactly what the Rule 5 Draft delivered to 13 overlooked talents, shaking up the prospect rankings for 10 MLB teams and sparking hope for fresh starts in the majors. If you're new to this, the Rule 5 Draft is like a talent grab bag where teams can select players from other organizations who have been in the minors for a certain number of years without getting a spot on the 40-man roster. It's a high-stakes move: once picked, these players must stay on the major league roster for the entire next season (or at least 90 days, accounting for any injury time) or risk being returned. This year's draft on Wednesday featured 13 selections – mostly right-handed pitchers, with one catcher – giving these prospects their golden ticket to The Show after being blocked by deeper farm systems.
These moves ripple through each team's Top 30 prospects list, adding new faces and removing others. We'll update the full rankings before the 2026 season kicks off, but right now, let's dive into how we adjusted the lists post-draft. And this is the part most people miss: while it opens doors for the selected players, it can leave gaps in the original teams' pipelines that might take years to fill.
- Grab some official Minor League swag (https://milbstore.com/?utmsource=milb.com&utmmedium=article&utmcampaign=article&utmcontent=milbprospect)
AMERICAN LEAGUE EAST
Red Sox
Lost: Jedixson Paez, RHP (No. 19)
Top 30 replacement: Tyler Uberstine, RHP (No. 30 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/redsox/tyler-uberstine-700413))
Boston decided against adding Paez to their 40-man roster following a frustrating right calf injury that sidelined him after just seven outings (covering 19 1/3 innings) at High-A Greenville. For beginners, protecting a player means securing them on the 40-man to shield them from the draft – Boston skipped that here. The 21-year-old phenom shines with his exceptional command (think pinpoint accuracy that scouts rate as plus-plus), and now he's swapping his Red Sox uniform for White Sox colors. Heading to Chicago without any Double-A or Triple-A seasoning, this could be a massive leap, but it's an exciting one. Stepping up to replace him is Tyler Uberstine, whom the Red Sox did protect back in November. This 26-year-old righty has a compelling backstory – he was even cut from USC's club team as a freshman! – but his game speaks volumes: a sneaky 92-94 mph fastball that pops thanks to his near-sidearm slot, making it tough for hitters to pick up. Uberstine might just carve out a role in Boston's rotation depth come 2026, adding that underdog vibe to their farm.
Yankees
Added: Cade Winquest, RHP (No. 30 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/yankees/cade-winquest-685464))
The Yankees usually enter the winter with a packed 40-man roster, so it's rare for them to dip into the Rule 5 pool – their last pick was way back in 2011. But this Cardinals right-hander caught their eye and lured them in. In 2025, Winquest delivered a solid 3.99 ERA, racking up 110 strikeouts over 106 innings split between High-A and Double-A. His standout offering is an upper-70s curveball with sharp, sweeping break that keeps batters guessing. He backs it with a mid-90s fastball and a low-80s slider that can hit average grades on good days. With their farm system hit hard by deadline trades this year – losing key pieces for immediate help – New York is betting on Winquest's potential. A little coaching in Tampa this spring could unlock another solid pitch, and who knows, maybe he'll debut in the Bronx sooner than expected. But here's where it gets controversial: Is raiding a rival's system like this fair play, or does it disadvantage smaller-market teams?
AMERICAN LEAGUE CENTRAL
Guardians
Added: Peyton Pallette, RHP (No. 19 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/guardians/peyton-pallette-688883))
This 2022 second-round pick from Arkansas gets to stay close to home – or at least in the same division. Snagged ninth overall from the White Sox, Pallette joins Cleveland without crossing state lines. The 6-foot-1 right-hander fully embraced a relief role in 2025, wrapping up with a 4.06 ERA, 86 punchouts, and holding opponents to a measly .191 average across 64 1/3 innings at Double-A and Triple-A. He heats things up at 94-96 mph with his fastball, complemented by a high-spin curve (averaging 2,840 rpm up at Triple-A, which means serious spin rate for tight movement) and a changeup that generates whiffs on over half its swings (50.8% whiff rate in Charlotte). The catch? His four-seamer can leak runs, especially to lefties, so it'll be fascinating to watch how the Guardians tweak his mix. For those just tuning in, spin rate is like the RPM on a car engine – higher means more bite on the pitch.
Tigers
Lost: RJ Petit, RHP (No. 30)
Top 30 replacement: Eduardo Valencia, 1B/C (No. 23 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/tigers/eduardo-valencia-680664))
Detroit dodged a bullet last year by not protecting Petit when he first became eligible, keeping him in the fold. This time, though, the towering reliever was the top overall pick, heading to the pitch-starved Rockies. Sliding in to fill the spot is Eduardo Valencia, protected in November, who jumps higher on our list to honor his stellar 2025 breakout. Plagued by injuries and subpar stats earlier in his career, this right-handed hitter exploded with a .311/.382/.559 line, including 24 homers in 103 games split between Double-A and Triple-A – his best work coming at the highest minor league level. He's refined his swing path for better launch angles, setting him up to blend average and pop in the majors. Position-wise, he's versatile at first base or catcher, but that's still TBD. And this is the part most people miss: Versatility like that could make him a trade chip or everyday guy – what do you think his ceiling is?
White Sox
Added: Jedixson Paez, RHP (No. 15 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/whitesox/jedixson-paez-699151)); Alexander Alberto, RHP (No. 21 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/whitesox/alexander-alberto-693739))
Lost: Peyton Pallette, RHP (No. 14)
Fresh off snagging the top spot in Tuesday's MLB Draft Lottery (https://www.mlb.com/milb/news/mlb-draft-lottery-results-2026?t=mlb-draft-coverage), the White Sox kept the momentum rolling at Winter Meetings by grabbing two Rule 5 arms while waving goodbye to Pallette, who landed with the Guardians. Paez screams upside: He'll hit 22 in January, boasts starter-level control (just 15 free passes in 116 innings over the last two years), and packs a 79-81 mph slider plus a mid-80s changeup that both project well. No upper-minors experience makes it a gamble, but for a rebuilding team like Chicago, why not test him in a future rotation? Alberto's another raw talent bet, also sans Double-A or Triple-A reps, but his tools dazzle: a 96-98 mph fastball (touching 101) with nasty cut that baffles hitters, paired with a mid-80s slider that sweeps for plus potential. At 6-foot-8, his extension is a weapon, though harnessing that frame for consistent strikes will be key at the MLB level. The Sox are loading up on pitching lottery tickets here – bold move or desperate?
AMERICAN LEAGUE WEST
Athletics
Lost: Daniel Susac, C (No. 11)
Top 30 replacement: Darwing Ozuna, OF (No. 30 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/athletics/darwing-ozuna-829048))
Oakland had been active in the Rule 5 major league phase every year since 2019, either picking or trading for selections. That run ends now, with the A's on the losing end as catcher Daniel Susac – known for his power potential and solid glove work – was taken by the Giants (via the Twins). In his place steps Darwing Ozuna, who earned the No. 30 slot. Previously ranked 16th on our 2025 international prospects list (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/international/darwing-ozuna-829048), this 6-foot-3 outfield prospect inked an $850,000 deal in January. His Rookie-level Dominican Summer League debut was rocky (.211/.301/.311 over 103 plate appearances), but picture him as a classic right fielder with growing power and a cannon for an arm. International signings like him often take time to acclimate, much like past stars such as Vladimir Guerrero Jr., so patience could pay off big.
NATIONAL LEAGUE EAST
Nationals
Added: Griff McGarry, RHP (No. 30 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/nationals/griff-mcgarry-676046))
Washington's revamped front office kept things divisional by poaching this ex-Phillies righty, eyeing his electric stuff. Control issues (like a whopping 24.5% walk rate in Triple-A relief last year) kept McGarry off Philly's roster, but shifting back to starting in 2025 helped him dial it in. His 93-95 mph fastball (hitting upper 90s) has a steep vertical plane that makes it sneaky effective, while his low-80s sweeper can dazzle as a plus-plus breaker. For a rebuilding Nats squad, that's tantalizing potential. New baseball ops president Paul Toboni shared with reporters, including MLB.com's Jessica Camerato, that they're still debating starter or reliever role for him – flexibility like that could be a game-changer.
Phillies
Added: Zach McCambley, RHP (No. 30 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/phillies/zach-mccambley-685112))
Since McGarry wasn't on Philly's Top 30 pre-draft, the Phillies bulked up by swiping McCambley from NL East foes, the Marlins. The 26-year-old has locked in as a reliever since 2023, delivering a sharp 2.90 ERA and 83 strikeouts in 62 innings across Double-A and Triple-A in 2025. His 83-85 mph slider boasts massive gloveside movement, bordering on plus-plus territory, and a snappier 88-91 mph cutter complements it perfectly. Cracking a loaded contender's bullpen as a Rule 5 guy is no easy feat, but his arsenal has that intriguing edge. But here's where it gets controversial: Should contenders like Philly prioritize these low-cost adds over developing their own, or does it stunt homegrown talent?
NATIONAL LEAGUE WEST
Giants
Added: Daniel Susac, C (No. 15 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/giants/daniel-susac-691740))
Minnesota scooped Susac fourth overall before flipping him to San Francisco for DSL backstop Miguel Caraballo. He won't unseat elite defender Patrick Bailey anytime soon, but Susac flashed big-league readiness with a .275/.349/.483 slash and career-best 18 homers in 97 Triple-A games for Las Vegas last year. The Pacific Coast League can inflate stats due to its hitter-friendly parks, so take that power with a grain of salt – but his improvements in framing pitches show MLB-caliber handling skills. Plus, his above-average arm could deter runners, boosting his stick-around odds. From Arizona college standout to potential backup, Susac's journey highlights how Rule 5 can revive careers.
Rockies
Added: RJ Petit, RHP (No. 26 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/2025/rockies/rj-petit-696275))
Standing 6-foot-8 and tipping the scales at 300 pounds, Petit is built for the thin air of Denver – a literal giant among pitchers. Despite a stellar 2.44 ERA and 79 strikeouts in 66 1/3 innings over Double-A and Triple-A this season, he couldn't crack Detroit's pen. Colorado sees him as a prime Rule 5 candidate to lock down. His 83-85 mph gyro slider – a true vertical dropper – should thrive at altitude, per the Rockies' scouts, and his fastball touches 98 mph for velocity punch. Upside might be capped, but his current command and stuff scream immediate bulk reliever in the NL West. For example, think of how Coors Field favors certain pitches; that slider could be a secret weapon.
So, what do you make of these Rule 5 shake-ups? Will guys like Paez or McGarry defy the odds and become stars, or is the pressure too much for unproven talent? And controversially, does the draft favor big spenders over patient builders? Drop your takes in the comments – agree, disagree, or share your bold predictions!
